Compare
Yoto vs Toniebox: an honest NZ comparison
Both are lovely screen-free audio players for kids. Here's how they differ, what they cost in New Zealand, and which suits which family.

Prices checked 15 November 2026. Yes, we rent Tonies, so we've tried to be extra fair.
The short answer
- Toniebox suits toddlers and preschoolers best. The figurines double as toys, and there's nothing to read or insert.
- Yoto suits slightly older kids, and families who want a clock, night light and Bluetooth speaker in one. Cards are thin and easy to store.
How they work
With a Toniebox, your child puts a Tonie figurine on top and it plays. Each Tonie is a character, like Bluey or the Gruffalo, so kids pick by who they want to hear.
With a Yoto player, your child slots a Yoto card into the top. A small pixel display shows a picture for the story, and there are buttons to change volume and skip.
Side by side
| Toniebox | Yoto | |
|---|---|---|
| How you play | Put a figurine on top | Slot a card into the top |
| Ages (per tonies / Kmart NZ) | 1 to 12+ | 3 to 12 (Yoto Player) |
| Screen | No screen | No screen; small pixel display |
| Players in NZ | Toniebox 2 $244.95, Lite set $169.95 (tonies.co.nz) | Yoto Player $189, Yoto Mini $139 (Kmart NZ) |
| Content | Tonies, most $34.95 each | Yoto cards, sold separately |
| Record your own | Creative Tonie ($29.95) | Make Your Own cards |
| Night light / wake clock | Toniebox 2: sleep timer light and sunrise alarm | Night light with okay-to-wake |
| Bluetooth speaker for your phone | No | Yes |
| Bluetooth headphones | Yes | Check the model |
Sources: Kmart NZ Yoto Player; Kmart NZ Yoto Mini; Techoutlet NZ Yoto Player; tonies support: Toniebox Lite vs Toniebox 2.
Where Toniebox wins
- Younger kids. A figurine is easier for a one or two-year-old than a card slot.
- The Tonies are toys in their own right, and kids love collecting and carrying them.
- Big-name characters: Bluey, Disney, PAW Patrol, Peppa Pig and many more.
- Tough, soft-sided Toniebox 2 that copes with being dropped and cuddled.
Where Yoto wins
- Older kids. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player for ages 3 to 12.
- Extras like the pixel display, okay-to-wake light, room thermometer and Bluetooth speaker.
- Cards are flat, so a big collection takes up less room.
- Kmart NZ's listing mentions free audio, including white noise and sleep sounds on Yoto Mini.
The cost over time
For either system, the player is a one-off cost but the content keeps adding up as your child grows. That's where renting helps. With Little Minds you can rent Tonies and swap one, some or all, once a month, so your child always has something new without a shelf full of Tonies they've outgrown.
Questions parents ask
Is Yoto or Toniebox better for a toddler?
For under-3s we'd lean Toniebox. tonies rates its boxes from age 1, and the chunky figurines are easy for little hands. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player for ages 3 to 12.
Is Yoto or Toniebox cheaper in NZ?
Players are close. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player at $189 and the Yoto Mini at $139. On tonies.co.nz, the Toniebox Lite My Story Set is $169.95 and Toniebox 2 is $244.95. Prices vary a lot between shops and sales.
Can you play Yoto cards on a Toniebox?
No. Yoto cards only play on Yoto players, and Tonies only play on Tonieboxes.
Can I rent Yoto cards from Little Minds?
Not at the moment. Little Minds rents Tonies and Tonieboxes.
Keep reading
Leaning Toniebox?
Try one for a month before you buy.