Compare

Yoto vs Toniebox: an honest NZ comparison

Both are lovely screen-free audio players for kids. Here's how they differ, what they cost in New Zealand, and which suits which family.

A green figure and a small red figure on a red Toniebox

Prices checked 15 November 2026. Yes, we rent Tonies, so we've tried to be extra fair.

The short answer

  • Toniebox suits toddlers and preschoolers best. The figurines double as toys, and there's nothing to read or insert.
  • Yoto suits slightly older kids, and families who want a clock, night light and Bluetooth speaker in one. Cards are thin and easy to store.

How they work

With a Toniebox, your child puts a Tonie figurine on top and it plays. Each Tonie is a character, like Bluey or the Gruffalo, so kids pick by who they want to hear.

With a Yoto player, your child slots a Yoto card into the top. A small pixel display shows a picture for the story, and there are buttons to change volume and skip.

Side by side

Toniebox details from tonies; Yoto details from Kmart NZ's product listings. Checked 15 November 2026.
TonieboxYoto
How you playPut a figurine on topSlot a card into the top
Ages (per tonies / Kmart NZ)1 to 12+3 to 12 (Yoto Player)
ScreenNo screenNo screen; small pixel display
Players in NZToniebox 2 $244.95, Lite set $169.95 (tonies.co.nz)Yoto Player $189, Yoto Mini $139 (Kmart NZ)
ContentTonies, most $34.95 eachYoto cards, sold separately
Record your ownCreative Tonie ($29.95)Make Your Own cards
Night light / wake clockToniebox 2: sleep timer light and sunrise alarmNight light with okay-to-wake
Bluetooth speaker for your phoneNoYes
Bluetooth headphonesYesCheck the model

Sources: Kmart NZ Yoto Player; Kmart NZ Yoto Mini; Techoutlet NZ Yoto Player; tonies support: Toniebox Lite vs Toniebox 2.

Where Toniebox wins

  • Younger kids. A figurine is easier for a one or two-year-old than a card slot.
  • The Tonies are toys in their own right, and kids love collecting and carrying them.
  • Big-name characters: Bluey, Disney, PAW Patrol, Peppa Pig and many more.
  • Tough, soft-sided Toniebox 2 that copes with being dropped and cuddled.

Where Yoto wins

  • Older kids. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player for ages 3 to 12.
  • Extras like the pixel display, okay-to-wake light, room thermometer and Bluetooth speaker.
  • Cards are flat, so a big collection takes up less room.
  • Kmart NZ's listing mentions free audio, including white noise and sleep sounds on Yoto Mini.

The cost over time

For either system, the player is a one-off cost but the content keeps adding up as your child grows. That's where renting helps. With Little Minds you can rent Tonies and swap one, some or all, once a month, so your child always has something new without a shelf full of Tonies they've outgrown.

Questions parents ask

Is Yoto or Toniebox better for a toddler?

For under-3s we'd lean Toniebox. tonies rates its boxes from age 1, and the chunky figurines are easy for little hands. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player for ages 3 to 12.

Is Yoto or Toniebox cheaper in NZ?

Players are close. Kmart NZ lists the Yoto Player at $189 and the Yoto Mini at $139. On tonies.co.nz, the Toniebox Lite My Story Set is $169.95 and Toniebox 2 is $244.95. Prices vary a lot between shops and sales.

Can you play Yoto cards on a Toniebox?

No. Yoto cards only play on Yoto players, and Tonies only play on Tonieboxes.

Can I rent Yoto cards from Little Minds?

Not at the moment. Little Minds rents Tonies and Tonieboxes.

Keep reading

Leaning Toniebox?

Try one for a month before you buy.

Rent a Toniebox